By now, even non-bitcoin enthusiasts may have heard of a fundraising process called initial coin offerings. The Securities and Exchange Commission has cracked down with accusations of fraud and scores of subpoenas this year. But the CEO of Overstock, which is under SEC investigation, says there’s a safer way to raise money through crypto: Security Token Offerings.
“It’s the new term,” Overstock CEO Patrick Byrne said. “The industry is distinguishing very clearly now between ICOs and STOS.”
This week, Overstock announced a $2.5 million investment in three-wheel car startup Elio Motors. The automaker also announced the launch of “ElioCoin” to fund production and made clear in an announcement it was a “security token offering.” The process is being led by Wall Street trading firm JonesTrading Institutional Services.
“It is a very clever offering, and could represent a whole new model for American entrepreneurship,” Byrne said.
Roughly $9.8 billion has been raised through ICOS since 2016, according to financial research firm Autonomous Next. That money flow has caught the attention of the SEC, which has warned of pump-and-dump schemes in ICOs, shut some down, and recently charged one backed by Floyd Mayweather and DJ Khalid with fraud.
In an ICO, coins or tokens are put up for sale as a form of crowdfunding. Instead of voting rights or dividends that come with shares of a company, “utility tokens” promise access to a network, platform, or service. But they’re often backed by an abstract idea, or nothing at all.
The process has facilitated the rise of cryptocurrencies like Dogecoin, a Shiba Inu dog meme-turned-cryptocurrency that has a passionate following on sites like Reddit. Whoppercoin, Pandacoin, Trumpcoin and PutinCoin have also raised money through initial coin offerings.
Similarly, in a Security Token Offering, you can buy coins or tokens in the offering. But unlike many ICOs, these tokens must be backed by something tangible like assets, profits, or revenue of the company. They act almost exactly like a share of a company but are “programmable,” to do things like conduct proxy voting, because they’re built on blockchain technology, according to one expert.
“You can program a token, but a static share certificate just sits there and collects dust,” said Trevor Koverko, CEO of Polymath, a platform that helps people launch Securities Tokens.
Securities and Exchange Commission Chairman Jay Clayton made it clear in March that all ICOS constitute securities. By using the term “security token offering,” issuers are being more upfront with regulators that what they’re trading are actually securities, Overstock’s Byrne said.
Fraud and bad players in the ICO market have been a setback for those trying to raise money in a compliant way, the CEO said.
“The ICO craze of last year created a toxic waste dump of financial assets. To me, that world of ICOs is a superfund site,” Byrne said. “What we’re developing is a mechanism so that there will be a legal way to go forward, and not create any new toxic waste.”
He called what some ICOs were doing “flagrantly illegal.”
“I think the SEC should essentially shut down the utility token world,” Byrne said. “Eventually the security offerings will just be done in lieu of the IPO in lieu of shares.”
Overstock is also under investigation. The CEO would not comment on the charges and made it clear that he was cooperating.
In an 8-K filing, Overstock said that in February the SEC requested “certain documents related to the Offering and the Tokens in connection with its investigation.” The company announced its ICO launch in October and said at the time the offering would be legally compliant with SEC rules.
Byrne’s company is moving aggressively into the blockchain space, and the CEO has said he plans to reorganize or sell the e-commerce business to focus on the technology underpinning bitcoin. Overstock launched its Medici Ventures division in 2014 to oversee those blockchain investments.
Shares of the e-commerce giant are down roughly 40 percent this year but in the past 12 months, have jumped more than 100 percent.